Mineral: Spessartine and Smoky Quartz
Locality: Wushan Spessartine prospects, Tongbei, Yunxiao, Zhangzhou Prefecture, Fujian Province, China
Description: Photo 3 – Tongbei Village and surrounding area. A Case Study: The “Wushan Spessartine Mine” The “Wushan Spessartine Mine” in Fujian, China, serves as a classic case study in fabricated mineral localities. Famed for producing exceptionally vibrant, “Fanta orange” Spessartine Garnets, this supposed mine never actually existed. It's a clever marketing name invented by some dealers to give their specimens a more exclusive and traceable-sounding origin. This practice, however, highlights a significant and persistent problem within the mineral trade. Adding to the confusion, numerous mountains in China share the name Wushan or a similar variant, such as Wuyishan. A particularly notable example is a region about 290 kilometers northwest of Tongbei, on the border with the neighboring province of Jiangxi, renowned for its fine teas and granite outcrops (see map). This specific location has also been erroneously cited by some vendors as the source of the Spessartine Garnet specimens. Pinpointing the True Source: The Tongbei Area This aerial photograph shows the region surrounding the former site of the so-called Tongbei Village. The landscape is now dotted with the remnants of various abandoned granite quarries, derelict dwellings, evidence of past farming, and several man-made lakes. It is difficult to pinpoint the precise origin of the “Wu Shan” Spessartine specimens because the region contains numerous large granite outcrops and many abandoned quarries. A site known as Tongbei village is situated approximately 300 meters west of a major quarry, formerly a primary source for construction granite. Based on aerial photography and limited online information, it is unclear whether Tongbei was a traditional village or a support settlement built for the quarry. However, its immediate proximity to the quarrying operations strongly suggests it was the latter. It is also noteworthy that the site, which appeared as “Tongbei Village” (GPS: 23.930744 Lat, 117.192602 Lon) on several versions of Google Earth over the past fifteen years, no longer exists. Recent aerial photographs (ca. 2025) from both commercial and military sources show that all surface structures have been removed and the area has been completely rehabilitated. Most of the other quarries in the area have also been rehabilitated. Kengzaiwei, the largest nearby settlement, is situated approximately one kilometre northwest of the main quarry and 500 metres north of the former site of Tongbei village. Approximately 1.8 kilometers west of the Tongbei mining area lies the summit of Wu Shan Mountain. As the region's highest point, it serves as a notable local tourist attraction. It's highly probable that the Spessartine specimens recovered from this region get their common name from this mountain. The only conclusion supported by this analysis is that the “Wushan Spessartine Mine” is a fiction. The true source of the specimens is almost certainly local quarries and outcrops near the former Tongbei settlement. The Power of a Name: Marketing and Provenance In the vibrant world of mineral collecting, a compelling and specific name can greatly enhance a specimen's appeal. These unique names often highlight a mineral's special qualities, helping it stand out in the market. In some instances, a distinctive name may be used to protect a new or sensitive discovery, allowing a source to be managed carefully without being overwhelmed by competitors. While this marketing can add a layer of mystique that elevates a specimen's prestige, it's helpful for collectors to be aware of how these names are used. For the collecting community, understanding a specimen's true origin is a deeply rewarding part of the hobby. Provenance — a specimen's documented history — adds to its story and is a cornerstone of a meaningful collection. For researchers, accurate location data is invaluable, as it contributes to our collective understanding of geology and mineralogy. Ultimately, transparency and clear information build a stronger, more trusting community for everyone, from dealers to hobbyists. This encourages collectors to engage in the fun of discovery by asking questions and learning the story behind each piece. Being curious and informed is a wonderful way for anyone to build a collection with confidence and pride. The Broader Challenge: Unraveling Chinese Localities Accurately determining the provenance of mineral specimens from China poses a significant and ongoing challenge. A confluence of linguistic barriers, inconsistencies in transliterating names to the Roman alphabet, and evolving administrative regions creates persistent difficulties for both researchers and collectors. A primary source of confusion is China's linguistic diversity. Alongside the official national language of Mandarin (Putonghua), numerous regions have distinct local tongues like Cantonese, Hokkien, and Hakka. Consequently, a single place can possess multiple names. For example, the city known today by its Mandarin name, Xiamen, was historically called Amoy, a name derived from its pronunciation in the local Hokkien dialect. This issue is compounded by a history of inconsistent romanization. Before Hanyu Pinyin became the international standard, various other systems were common, including Wade-Giles (e.g., Pei-ching) and Chinese postal romanization (e.g., Peking). These older, often conflicting spellings persist in historical documents, creating multiple Western identities for what is now known as Beijing and obscuring a location's modern identity. China's dynamic administrative geography adds another layer of complexity. Provincial, prefectural, and county boundaries have been redrawn countless times throughout history. A village that was once part of a specific county may now belong to a different one or may have been absorbed into a sprawling urban district with a new name. This makes reconciling historical records with modern maps incredibly difficult, especially when a record refers to a prefecture that no longer exists as a political entity. Furthermore, the Chinese cultural concept of a “hometown” (jíguàn) often refers to an ancestral clan's place of origin, not one's actual birthplace. An individual might identify with a small, ancient village their family left generations ago, a place that can be nearly impossible to locate on a contemporary map. These overlapping historical, cultural, and administrative layers make pinpointing a specific Chinese locality a significant puzzle for mineral collectors and historians.

All pictures, text, design © Forum FMF 2006-2025