FMF - Friends of Minerals Forum, discussion and message board

[Ning]

About 5 years ago while travelling in Peru I came across a chunk of schorl coated in crystalline rose quartz from Brazil. I couldn’t find any other references of this find.

I recently purchased an indicolite tourmaline coated with way more saturated crystalline rose quartz from Afghanistan. I can’t find any references to this find.

I’m not new to mineral collecting but I am new to caring about where they come from. Where is the best place to find information about this kind of thing? Are there any other tourmaline rose quartz association finds?

Pics attached.

[James Catmur]

Let's see if anyone else can help you (I do not collect Tourmaline so not a subject I can help you with)

[Ning]

Thanks! I’d love to find out more. 🙏

[James Catmur]

Try looking at this page as it gives numerous 'rose quartz' localities

https://www.gemdat.org/gem-3456.html
(link normalized by FMF)

[Pete Richards]

I used Mindat to search for rose quartz. Under associations there are listed 16 images of rose quartz with schorl. 12 of these would be of interest to this thread; all are from Taquaral, Itinga, Minas Gerais, Brazil.

Filtering the ~600 photos of rose quartz for association with elbaite or with tourmaline produced a handful of additional localities, but none of the images showed rose quartz crystals encrusting large showy tourmaline crystals like your specimen from Afganistan.

The reverse approach - searching tourmaline pictures for association with rose quartz is less satisfactory. The reported common associations do not include rose quartz, and the filtering approach returns all tourmaline with "rose" or "quartz" in the description. 45 images were identified, only one of which has rose quartz, as opposed to rose colored tourmaline with quartz or some other unwanted combination of "rose" and "quartz". This one image is of a specimen from Alto da Pittora, Minas Gerais.

This is clearly not an exhaustive search of all tourmaline, but Mindat is easily searched in this way and pretty comprehensive.

[lluis]

Hi, all

Just looking at what was said in last post, because I did same...
With same poor results.
Not finding in Mindat rose quartz in Afghanistan...
Then, maybe just fake items? Chinese are well known for having sold cinnabar in matrix that were just matrix glued pieces of cinnabar. Gluing rose quartz (or pink; one if for non crystals one; other is for crystallized one. I just do not remember the distinction said in Mineralogical Record many years ago) to a core of tourmaline... Not unlikely, taking in account that who did (name known... Should dig in MR... which I have not the urgency to do...) the glued cinnabar was an artist in that...
Sometimes, the easier answer is the good answer (Occam's razor, lightened.... I still think that hard one is true...)

With best wishes

LLuís

[Jordi Fabre]

Both pieces appear to be forgeries, curiously both related to rose quartz

[Ning]

Hi Jordi. Curious what makes you say that? How would I tell if they were forgeries? Would soaking in acetone loosen any glue?

It would be disappointing if they were, but I’d rather know for sure than not know.

[Ning]

[Ning]

Hi Pete,

Thanks for your search and tips. I’ll have a look.

Cheers!

[lluis]

Hi, Ning

No, I was not trying to say that pink quartz in your samples are cinnabar. They look to me as pink quartz.
Just that maybe it has been an "artist" work and pink quartz could have been glued to tourmaline.
Tourmalines are many times associated with quartz, just never seen any with pink quartz.
Or, another possibility is that pieces were found.... and an "artist" again have dyed the quartz to pink, with a solvent paint/ink...
The one you show from Afghanistan, looks to me like a Brazilian one (besides, very nice!).
Or if from Afghanistan really, could be also dyed..
I suppose that should have the item in hand, or better, do an analysis if pink quartz is really pink quartz (should have, if I do not remember badly, some impurities that are characteristic of it...)
Sorry not to be of more help...
With best wishes

Lluís

[Ning]

Ok thanks. I’ve engaged a mineralogy and gemology lab in Singapore to test these for dying, glue and any other alteration/fabrication. Hopefully this will clear this up one way or another. I live in Thailand, so it’ll take me a while to get over there. Any other specifics I should be looking for?

They will provide a report for me. I’ll post the results here.

[Ning]

Ok, tracked down the provenance of this a bit through about 4 hands to me from source. There were 3 that came out of the pocket. Tiny find. Reputable source. Photos of the other pieces attached.

[James Catmur]

What is the locality? We can add it to the photos

[Jordi Fabre]